January 15,
2005 WASHINGTON
(AP) - President
Bush said Saturday
that Social
Security "is
on the road
to bankruptcy"
and will be
unable to pay
promised benefits
to future generations,
raising the
stakes in a
major political
battle with
Democrats.
Bush used his
weekly radio
address to try
to build support
for his plan
to allow workers
to divert part
of their Social
Security payroll
taxes into private
investment accounts.
Democrats accuse
him of exaggerating
the problem
to sell a plan
that would scale
back Social
Security.
Bush said
the cost of
fixing the system
grows larger
each year, and
he quoted Social
Security trustees
as saying that
waiting just
one year would
add $600 billion
to the price
of a solution.
"If we
do not act now,
government will
eventually be
left with two
choices: dramatically
reduce benefits
or impose a
massive economically
ruinous tax
increase,"
the president
said. "Leaving
our children
with such a
mess would be
a generational
betrayal."
According
to experts,
in the year
2018 Social
Security will
start paying
out more in
benefits than
it collects
in payroll taxes.
In 2042, it
will be able
to cover only
about 73 percent
of benefits
owed, unless
changes are
made.
Democrats
countered Bush's
arguments in
their address
an hour later.
Sen. Debbie
Stabenow of
Michigan said
her party is
waiting for
a detailed proposal
from Bush. But
she said one
White House
memo suggests
he wants to
cut benefits
for future workers
by up to 45
percent.
"The benefit
cuts would apply
to all seniors
— even
those who choose
not to invest
in privatized
accounts,"
Stabenow contended.
Social Security
does face long-term
challenges,
she said, but
private investment
isn't the answer.
"America's
insurance policy
was never meant
to be a privatized
401(k)plan or
a high-risk
investment,"
she said. "It
was meant to
be the secure
foundation for
your retirement."
Stabenow said
Congress should
promote savings
by individuals
to supplement
Social Security.
"Too few
Americans are
saving for their
future, and
we must address
that,"
she said.
Bush said
the system is
sound for people
nearing retirement
and current
retirees. "But
for younger
workers, Social
Security is
on the road
to bankruptcy.
And if we do
not fix it now,
the system will
not be able
to pay the benefits
promised to
our children
and grandchildren,"
he added.
Bush said
earlier this
week he wants
Congress to
approve major
changes before
the end of May,
but he has not
offered any
details of his
plan for private
investment accounts.
Democrats
say the model
most often described
would cost more
than $2 trillion
over the first
decade alone
and hasten the
program's fiscal
problems. The
White House
is considering
letting workers
divert up to
two-thirds of
the 6.2 percent
paid in payroll
taxes into investment
accounts, up
to perhaps $1,000
to $1,300 a
year, administration
officials have
said.
Bush said
a child born
now could expect
less than a
2 percent return
after inflation
on the money
they pay into
Social Security.
"A conservative
mix of bonds
and stocks would
over time produce
a larger return,"
he said.
Democrats
disagreed.
"Rather
than averting
the so-called
'crisis' it
decries, the
administration's
plan will create
a crisis where
currently only
a challenge
exists,"
said Rep. John
Spratt of South
Carolina, top
Democrat on
the House Budget
Committee.
Sen. Jack
Reed, D-R.I.,
added: "The
kind of plan
the president
supports only
achieves solvency
for Social Security
through massive
cuts in guaranteed
benefits. Private
accounts actually
weaken the solvency
of the program."
In remarks
Friday to members
of the U.S.
Chamber of Commerce
, Joshua Bolten,
the president's
budget chief,
said the 70-year-old
program has
failed to change
with the times.
The number of
workers paying
Social Security
taxes has shrunk
compared to
the number of
retirees whose
benefits they
are supporting,
yet more than
20 tax increases
in recent decades
have not fixed
the imbalance,
he said.
"All these
tax increases
did was push
those problems
out to be solved
another day,"
Bolten said.
"That day
has arrived."
< Back
to News
|